How each one works
Ring twisting. Yarn is fed down from delivery rollers to a traveller that runs around a ring, and is wound onto a bobbin on the spindle. Each turn of the spindle puts in one turn of twist. The twist level is the ratio of spindle speed to delivery speed.
Two-for-one twisting. The feed package sits still inside a pot on the spindle. Yarn is drawn off the top, down through the hollow spindle, out through a rotating storage disc at the bottom, and up around the outside of the pot as a balloon to the take-up. The yarn gets one turn inside the spindle and a second in the balloon, so each turn of the spindle puts in two turns of twist.
The main differences
| Ring twister | Two-for-one twister | |
|---|---|---|
| Twist per spindle turn | One | Two |
| Output at the same speed and twist | Baseline | About double |
| Take-up package | Small bobbin, needs rewinding | Large cross wound package, ready to use |
| Knots or splices per kilogram | More, from small bobbins | Few |
| Feed | Singles from a creel, plied on the machine | Assembly wound package, plied before the machine |
| Yarn stress | Lower, gentle on delicate yarns | Higher, from the balloon and the storage disc |
| Flexibility for short runs | Good | Fair, feed packages must be prepared |
| Twist range | Very wide | Wide, limited at very high and very low twist |
Where two-for-one wins
For volume production of plied staple and filament yarns, two-for-one is usually the more economical machine. Twice the delivery speed, a large knot free package straight off the machine and no separate rewinding step add up to lower cost per kilogram.
It asks for good preparation. The singles have to be assembly wound together, at even tension, onto a package that fits the pot. A poor assembly wound package gives corkscrew yarn, breaks and uneven twist, and no setting on the twister will fix it.
Where ring twisting wins
- Delicate and difficult yarns. The yarn path is simpler and the stress is lower, so yarns that fibrillate, abrade or have low elongation often run better.
- Very heavy counts such as twines and cords, where the balloon on a two-for-one would be too large to control.
- Very high twist and special constructions.
- Short runs and many products. Singles go straight on the creel with no assembly winding, so changes are quick.
- Fancy and effect yarns, where separate feed rollers control each component.
Other machines worth knowing
- Up twisters take yarn off a rotating supply package upward to a take-up. They are simple and suit filament yarns at low to medium twist.
- Cabling machines, also called direct cablers, combine two yarns in one step without twisting the individual yarns, at high speed. They are the standard for tyre cord and carpet yarn.
- Covering machines wrap one yarn around another, for example around an elastane core.
How to choose
Four questions settle most cases.
- How much of each product per week? Long runs of few products point to two-for-one. Many short runs point to ring.
- What package does the next process need? If it needs a large knot free package, ring twisting adds a rewind.
- How does the yarn cope with stress? Trial it. Some yarns that look robust will not tolerate the two-for-one balloon at economic speeds.
- What can your team prepare and maintain? A two-for-one line needs assembly winders and people who understand them.
To compare output between the two on your own figures, use the twisting production calculator, which handles both machine types.
Buying second hand
Plenty of good twisting machinery changes hands used. The checks that matter are spindle condition and run out, the state of the drive, traverse wear, electrical and control parts that may no longer be supported, and whether the spindle gauge and pot size actually suit your feed packages. Paul can inspect and advise as part of machinery installation and commissioning.